Nightmare Hall #4 The Wish
by Diane Hoh
Young adult · ages 13–18 · grades 8–12 · 720L · 2013
Why we'd hand it over
Solid late-90s YA suspense—wish-fulfillment premise draws readers in, but the plot turns hinge on convenient revelations rather than earned mystery logic; nostalgia lift if you read it at 14, thin re-read appeal.